I have that one. It works good for it's purpose. But I never had use for the tube thing. I used to try to catch the crickets with the tube and throw it in the cage. But I found that it was a waste of time. Now I just slide open the little door at the top and shake them out of the cup. I like this one besides the DIY cup because I know it will last longer. The DIY cup works great, but I have a feeling you will have to replace it a couple of times throughout the year. That's the small price you have to pay for the DIY cup. I usually throw some crickets in the feeder cup, with a small carrot, the night before. That way I can just toss them in the cage faster in the morning and go back to sleep.